Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
Skip to main content
Advertisement
Advertisement

Gaetz outlines DCF overhaul as Zuraff case nears conclusion

Gaetz, R-Crestview, said he is drafting one or more bills with Sens. Jason Pizzo, NPA-Hollywood; Jennifer Bradley, R-Fleming Island; and Erin Grall, R-Fort Pierce; and that many of 34 recommendations issued by the Fifth Judicial Circuit grand jury will be incorporated into them.

The grand jury, which released a report on the case Aug. 27, described “heartbreaking systemic patterns of neglect and abuse, abrogation of statutory responsibilities, as well as operational failures” within the department, Gaetz said, referring to the report.

Joy Zuraff (left) stands with State Sen. Jason Pizzo (right) during a press conference at the Santa Rosa County Courthouse on Sept. 4.

He said the panel found children were being exploited, abused and neglected, and that some children died.

“When the department was confronted with its failures, the department delayed, denied, lied and then did nothing,” Gaetz said.

The news conference occurred at the same time as a dependency hearing for Joy Zuraff, whose daughter was removed from their Navarre home in March 2024, when the child was 5, and placed with a foster caregiver in Jacksonville. The girl returned home June 10.

A final hearing is set for Dec. 10, marking the six months of post-reunification work required by state law.

Zuraff is under a gag order and did not speak at the news conference. Pizzo, an independent representing parts of Broward and Miami-Dade counties, has represented her since February and said he has spent more than 2,000 hours on the case.

Gaetz said the legislation would reform Chapter 39 of state statutes, starting with the premise that DCF may contract out services but not accountability, and the contracts should be performance-based and should have oversight from the department, the Legislature and the governor’s office, with family rights not varying from county to county.

Other provisions would create legal consequences for agency staff and contractors who falsify documents or testimony and would allow parents or guardians to present evidence and challenge department actions without that being used against them in proceedings.

The proposed legislation would restrict placing children great distances from their families when DCF cannot find closer alternatives and would require contractors to employ credentialed clinicians, with fines and contract cancellations if those needs are not met.

Gaetz said a decision to seek termination of parental rights should be approved by a DCF secretary instead of a lower-tiered employee, noting that the justice system treats parental termination as heavily as the death penalty. Gaetz noted that judges should have a stronger role as a “check” on the department.

The final provision would repeal sovereign immunity for DCF contractors. Gaetz said the change affects only civil liability and said contractors would not be immune from criminal charges if the legislation is passed.

Gaetz noted that he does not want investigators discouraged from removing children in actual danger and said hundreds of DCF employees are qualified and committed.

“If DCF and some of its contractors have failed, so has the Florida Legislature, and so have I,” he said. “I wish I could have, and I wish I would have known more and done more then, but now I will.”

Pizzo noted that Zuraff was a single mom and was expected to drive 13 hours round trip to see her child.

“She was set up to fail,” he said. “Every obstacle was inserted.”

A former assistant state attorney, Pizzo said the testimony he reviewed was largely hearsay. He defended Chapter 39’s confidentiality provision in principle, saying it has eroded accountability.

Aden suspends Flock camera program under FDOT order

FDOT, on Aug. 31, pulled every active permit for ALPRs and ordered law enforcement agencies to pull the devices from state rights of way.

DOT cited an “exponential increase” in deployments, along with reports of misuse and data privacy concerns, in its decision. Agencies have 30 days to remove the cameras or the department will remove any readers that remain.

“From the very start of this discussion, I said that if a judge ruled these cameras are unconstitutional, or the governor determined they violated the law, we would certainly comply,” said Sheriff Eric Aden in a news release. “Though LPR technology has not been ruled unconstitutional, nor did the Governor determine it unlawful or illegal through legislation, the FDOT Memorandum eliminates our ability to use them.”

Most of the cameras the sheriff’s office uses, supplied by vendor Flock Safety, sit on state rights of way. Aden says the department is going a step further by removing cameras from county roadways as well.

“This is disappointing from a public safety standpoint. It’s been a valuable tool in solving crime and protecting lives,” Aden added.

The sheriff’s office stated it will notify Flock Safety and work through contract timelines for removal. The agency did not rule out using the technology again but said it will wait for “clearer legal guidance” before any further action.

Local leaders react to Walton County FLOCK decision

On Aug. 25, Walton County commissioners voted to end the use of Flock cameras on county right of way. Chairman Brad Drake passed the gavel to Commissioner Tony Anderson to make the motion, saying he did not agree with them.

The motion was seconded by Commissioner Dan Curry, who initially brought the item to the meeting for discussion.

According to Walton County officials, the Walton County Sheriff’s Office operates roughly 106 of the 130 cameras found in the county. County Attorney Clay Adkinson said the board’s authority stops at the right of way, meaning cameras in city limits and along state highways will not be affected.

Santa Rosa County Commission Chairman Colten Wright said in a text message Aug. 26 that the cameras have produced arrests in serious cases and that abuse of the system by individual officers elsewhere should not decide the question locally.

“I believe license plate readers have been effective in apprehending dangerous criminals and saving the lives of women and children being trafficked,” Wright said. “I won’t let a handful or rouge law enforcement officers who’ve illegally abused the system to dictate what happens in the future and how the public is kept safe.”

Santa Rosa County Commissioner Kerry Smith, who has in the past questioned the Santa Rosa County Sheriff’s Office budget, drew a line between criticizing what the agency spends and limiting how it operates.

“I’d never be a commissioner that stood in the way of a law enforcement agency’s ability to fight crime,” Smith said.

Wright said the technology is not new, noting that cameras have been in use for years along highways, at bridge toll booths and on patrol cars.

“When traveling on a public roadway, motorists have no expectation of privacy,” he said.

Wright also compared the cameras to other law enforcement tools, saying officers have been found to have used force, firearms and Tasers without justification without those tools being taken from officers who use them properly.

Curry said his concern in Walton County was that the cameras will not stay license plate readers, citing reports on Flock expanding use of artificial intelligence and the possibility of pairing the cameras with facial recognition.

Santa Rosa County Commissioner-elect Dean Light, who will be replacing current Commissioner Ray Eddington, says he is willing to look at the issue.

“I can see where the use is for the sheriff’s department. If there’s a case going on or something like that, where they need some surveillance. But just general, out there? No,” Light said.

In Okaloosa County, Commission Chairman Trey Goodwin offered a statement on the issue. Godwin was the only commissioner to respond to the question.

“Okaloosa County is continuing to focus its attention on removing automated traffic enforcement cameras because they impose penalties on the registered owners without first establishing who was actually driving the vehicle.

Flock cameras present a different policy question because they are used as investigative tools to assist law enforcement in solving crimes and responding to emergency situations. The Okaloosa County Sheriff’s Office has adopted strict safeguards and procedures for using that technology.”

On Aug. 26, Gov Ron DeSantis also weighed in on FLOCK cameras at a press conference at Florida International University in Miami. DeSantis called for the Florida Legislature to take action.

“I think these cameras, the license plate readers, I think it’s out of control,” he said.

DeSantis’ main point during his remarks was the he believed the cameras would threaten civil liberties and lead Florida to become a “surveillance state.”

For law enforcement to access the system, searches require a case number and repeated searches are flagged.

Automated license plate readers photograph passing vehicles, converting the plate to text and stamping the photo with a time and location. Flock Safety, based in Atlanta, says images and footage are deleted after 30 days unless local law enforcement says differently.

Crestview moves toward ordinance for cottage food stands

City Manager Jessica Leavins told the council the city has fielded repeated questions from residents about home-based businesses as the style of business has picked up popularity in recent months. She said staff wanted direction before writing an ordinance amending the city’s land development code.

Under the guidelines Leavins presented, a stand could be no larger than 20 square feet and no taller than 8 feet. Customers would park in the seller’s driveway rather than on the right of way or in yards, and stands could only operate during daylight hours any day of the week.

The time restriction mirrors existing rules regarding yard sales.

“We’re not trying to discourage small business, while at the same time we want to make sure that there are regulations to keep everyone safe,” she said.

The city cannot regulate what is sold, as that is determined by the state. Leavins said the only thing the city can influence is what she described as “home occupation.”

After a question posed by Mayor Pro Tem Doug Capps on whether the businesses face outside review, such as from a health department, Leavins said state rules govern health and safety concerns.

As to who handles complaints, Leavins said those would be dealt with by code enforcement officers.

Councilman Shannon Hayes said his main concern was stands lingering, comparing them to yard sales that stretch past a weekend.

“They’ll start Friday and they’ll still be there next Friday,” Hayes said. “It’s not just sitting out their side of the road until the next morning.”

Councilwoman Dusty Allison said many of the sellers are stay-at-home mothers adding to household income and noted that she is glad that the city’s role would be small in scope.

After a question from Councilman Sylvester Echols, Leavins said the city’s ordinance would not overrule current regulations set by a homeowners association.

Mayor JB Whitten asked whether the council was comfortable with having staff return at a later date with a draft ordinance, and members agreed. Any ordinance would first go before the Planning and Development Board before returning to the council.

Crestview, Okaloosa County plan joint animal control operation

The agreement divides operating costs for animal control and shelter 50-50. A new shelter will be built in one of the city’s existing buildings, with the county covering 65% of the costs. Crestview is contributing the land and structure, according to Deputy County Administrator Craig Coffey.

Coffey said the building was constructed in 2020 and is about 7,500 square feet.

The county’s animal control budget had been slated to rise to about $900,000 this year, and county officials say the partnership will reduce that ask to $450,000. Coffey said Crestview currently spends $600,000 a year on animal control, meaning the county’s half would be $300,000.

The city will still need to provide officers and vehicles.

The move follows the county moving to stand up its own animal control operation this summer after the Panhandle Animal Welfare Society declined to renew a service agreement with the county it held for more than 20 years.

Commissioners in June chose a scaled-back model, known to county officials as animal control light, that only responds to bites, cruelty and neglect cases and loose livestock over strays and owner surrenders.

Coffey said Crestview provides higher services than that, falling somewhere between a full-service animal control model and the county’s limited model.

Coffey said the county will initially operate the limited version in the unincorporated areas and then grow toward the city’s service levels as resources grow.

Commissioner Trey Goodwin noted that the final cost remains unsettled.

“It just reminded me how expensive this venture is probably going to get,” he said.

“In my tenure, we’ve never had in house animal control,” he added. “In fact, I’m not sure anybody sitting up here has ever worked with Okaloosa County running its own animal control, so this is new.”

Crestview City Manager Jessica Leavins told commissioners the partnership would help both governments respond more effectively.

“Animals don’t know jurisdiction lines,” Leavins said.

Coffey said the agreement would also allow county inmates to work at the facility.

Before the issue came up, commissioners voted to add an item to the agenda to approve the purchase of two fully assembled animal patrol vehicles for no more than $44,000, including shipping, with advance payment.

Public Safety Director Pat Maddox said the county first tried to reuse three low-mileage F-250s, but the animal control beds cost up to $20,000 each and would take up to 10 months to build.

The assembled vehicles, which have air conditioning in the animal compartment, can arrive in two weeks.

Okaloosa Schools aren’t advertising a tax increase this year

Finance Director Julie Perry walked school board members through the proposed budget on July 27. The upcoming budget has a proposed millage rate of 5.372, down 0.05 mills and below the rollback rate.

One mill is $1 for every $1,000 of a property’s taxable value. If a home in Crestview is worth $200,000, that equates to about $1,065 a year for schools.

Most of that rate isn’t up to the school board. The Florida Department of Education sets the rate, and districts have to charge it. If Okaloosa County decided not to enforce it, it would lose the $145.5 million the state sends it.

However, the state-imposed rate has been falling for decades, down from 6.53 mills more than 30 years ago.

The issue is that Florida pays districts by enrollment. District officials expect about 1,200 fewer students to be enrolled in the district this year, resulting in $11.1 million less in funding.

Enrollment has been falling statewide, mostly because of the Family Empowerment Scholarship, which is open to any student regardless of income. Perry explained that the district made cuts to save $4.8 million by cutting teacher positions tied to enrollment.

However, that still left a $6.3 million gap.

Additional costs, including Pineview School coming online, new textbooks and rising insurance costs, increased the district’s projected shortfall to $17.6 million.

New state money helped offset some of that shortfall. Perry explained that the $6.1 million the district received is slightly less than what the Florida Legislature discussed. Another $1.9 million is already earmarked for tenured teachers.

That brought the remaining gap to $12.1 million.

The district then tried to close that gap by cutting teacher positions, closing Mary Esther and Longwood elementary schools, reorganizing staffing at the central office in Niceville, cutting department budgets, and paying for facilities staff and bus drivers from building repair funds.

Those measures left $1.8 million to spare, mostly money Perry said is for any remaining salary increases or unanticipated costs. Further adding to the headache is the possibility that funding for the school resource officer program might go away.

First discussed at an Okaloosa County Commission workshop on July 21, commissioners rejected a proposal by Commission Chairman Trey Goodwin to stop funding the SRO program in favor of a reduced tax rate.

Perry explained that since the Parkland school shooting in 2018, the county and the district have split the cost of the SRO program nearly 50-50. Goodwin questioned whether that split was fair because the district covers nearly half of its share with Safe Schools funding, to the tune of $2.9 million, with another $1.4 million coming from its own operating budget.

School board members said that money was never a bonus. The state never sent that funding until 2018, Perry said. It took money out of general per-student funding and reappropriated it.

“They didn’t give us any more money,” Board Member Brett Hinely said. “They just said you will now have to spend it on mental health or hardening, or whatever you’re going to do in your district. So it’s not a grant.”

According to state records, Okaloosa County schools have spent $5.37 million on SROs, with other funding going toward middle and high school correction programs and behavior programs. None went toward bullying or suicide prevention, according to expense reports from the 2017-18 through 2020-21 school years.

Superintendent Marcus Chambers laid out the worst-case scenario. The SRO program costs about $8.4 million, and the county pays $4.4 million. If the county walked away, a district placeholder of $1.6 million would become $4.4 million, or an extra $2.8 million on top of the $17.6 million it already absorbed.

The district has $1.8 million in reserve.

Board Member Lamar White recalled former Sheriff Larry Ashley telling the board that students in Okaloosa schools are residents, too, and deserve protection.

“I think the last place the general public wants to find us a way to balance the budget is going to be on the protection of children,” Board Member Parker Destin said.

Chambers said deputies are only one layer of school security, with other layers being paid for with building funds. He has spoken with County Administrator John Hofstad and expects more conversations going forward.

Okaloosa leaders brace for impact as property tax legislation heads to November ballot

The proposal would eventually eliminate property taxes on homesteaded properties under $250,000 by 2028, phasing out ad valorem revenue that cities rely on for public safety, infrastructure and quality of life services.

Destin Mayor Bobby Wagner said his city, which already has one of the lowest property tax rates in Florida, would lose roughly $937,000 per year, a 6.28% reduction. He noted that 51% of Destin’s homesteaded residents currently pay an average of $197 per year to the city, meaning most homeowners would see their bill drop to zero under the full exemption.

“It’s easy to say yes to lower taxes,” Wagner said. “The harder decision for the voter and for us in office will be if income is lower, what outputs are we going to cut?”

Wagner said Destin’s financial standing, with a “rainy day” fund twice the state requirement, gives the city some cushion, but cautioned against treating the measure as a cost-free win for taxpayers.

“No taxes is a great bumper sticker,” he said. “But as an elected official, I have to live withing the reality of a balance sheet.”

Wagner also dismissed the Legislature’s stance on local government waste at a time when the state recently paid $84 million for Norriego Point when it was sold for a fraction of that price.

In October 2025, the State of Florida acquired four acres of land on Norriego Point, land built by dredging Destin Harbor, from Pointe Mezzanine LLC. The land was owned by Bobby Guidry, an Okaloosa County megadonor who was convicted in the largest riverboat gambling fraud in Louisiana history in the mid-90s

“Those that are doing the right thing and being accountable to the taxpayers of their districts are getting impacted for something they didn’t do,” Wagner said.

In Crestview, City Manager Jessica Leavins said the impact would be steeper. With 41% of the city’s property homesteaded, Crestview stands to lose $2.7 million in the first year, about 20% of the general fund, rising to nearly $3.9 million by 2028, a loss of around 30%

Leavins

“$2.7 million is a lot of money,” Leavins said. “20% of any budget is going to be a substantial number, and that’s just the first year.”

Leavins said the city is already exploring creatives solutions but acknowledged that some service reductions are likely unavoidable.

“We’re looking to minimize that as much as possible,” Leavins said.

She also raised concerns about a provision in the bill’s final language, Section G, which allows municipalities some flexibility in how they spend their remaining property tax revenue beyond core services, but that language is vague and open to interpretation.

“If it’s broad and we are allowed to continue to fund those services, we are going to do our best to find a way,” Leavins said.

Leavins added that the city will take a more conservative approach to this year’s budget cycle, avoiding new positions or projects that might need to be cut in the future.

Florida League of Cities Vice President, and Shalimar Mayor, Mark Franks said the proposal, regardless of its intent, moves the decision-making process away from local communities and puts the purse in Tallahassee.

“A proposal this significant warranted more time and a comprehensive fiscal analysis before moving forward,” said Franks. “Eliminating property taxes doesn’t eliminate the cost; it just shifts the burden, and no one has shown how the math works.”

Franks said Florida’s cities remain partners in the success of the state, but need tools, like property tax income, to care for the wellbeing of their residents.

“When you remove the ability for communities to fund their own services locally, those decisions inevitably move further from the people they affect,” said Franks.

All three officials emphasized the importance of voter education ahead of November’s election. Leavins invited Crestview residents to attend budget workshops, the first scheduled for July 15, and urged them to contact their council members directly if concerns arise.

Wagner said his focus between now and election day will be ensuring residents understand the trade-offs before they cast their vote.

“If you want lower taxes, what are you willing to give up?” Wagner said. “As long as we have an educated vote on what we’re willing to give up, then the will of the people must be. Because that’s what democracy is supposed to be.”

Crestview Approves Use of Federal Forfeiture Funds for Police Equipment, Training

The approved funding includes:

  • $15,000 for a new K-9 dog, including training and equipment
  • $15,000 for crime scene photography 3D scanning equipment
  • $7,000 for a tactical pole-mounted camera system
  • $2,583 for GPS tracking and mapping systems, including software and equipment

The forfeiture funding stems from the department’s participation in a multi-agency drug task force that coordinates with federal law enforcement. In cases that result in convictions, assets tied to criminal activity may be seized. The federal government then redistributes those funds to participating local agencies, with spending restricted to specific law enforcement purposes and subject to local governing body approval.

Police vehicles are parked in the Crestview Police Department’s lot. Recently, the Crestview City Council authorized the use of forfeiture funds to purchase new equipment and fund training programs. (Photo by Lindsey Stroud)

Crestview Police Chief Stephen McCosker said the proposed purchases represent “a good use of the funds.”

McCosker noted that Crestview’s Police Officer of the Year was assigned to the task force responsible for generating the forfeiture revenue.

“These funds are coming from his efforts in that role,” McCosker said.

He also emphasized the value of K-9 units in past investigations and the need to maintain a balanced program with dogs at different stages of service.

“Some of those funds were collected because of the use of K-9 programs,” McCosker said. “We don’t get all the dogs at the same time … we need different dogs at different stages of their work life.”

McCosker also highlighted the department’s SWAT team, which recently executed five simultaneous search warrants, underscoring the need for enhanced safety equipment.

“A pole camera is not something that would be fixed in a location – it’s used for officer safety during high-risk search warrants,” he said. “We can extend that camera further than a person can safely go.”

He added that the department had previously sought funding for GPS tracking and mapping systems, but available grant funding had fallen short.

The total cost of the requested items is $39,583, below the approximately $43,000 currently available in forfeiture funds. McCosker said the department also expects to receive an additional $30,000 in future forfeiture revenue.

The City Council approved the request in a 4-0 vote, with one member absent.

Sidewalk staining project funding diverted to multi-use path

The city of Crestview first published a bid in January, soliciting proposals for the cleaning, staining and sealing of concrete sidewalks along Main Street and several intersecting side streets.

At the CRA meeting, city staff requested approval to amend the sidewalk staining project and redirect the allocated funds to another initiative: a multi-use path that will connect Main Street to Twin Hills Park.

Current sidewalk in downtown Crestivew. (Photo by Lindsey Stroud)

The sidewalk staining project was originally part of the broader Main Street streetscape improvement plan.

In 2024, the City Council approved a contract with Bullard Excavation Inc. to improve downtown Crestview, including widening sidewalks to meet ADA standards, adding benches and creating new parking spaces, among other updates. Not all of Main Street’s sidewalks have been updated.

Sidewalk that has not been completed on south Main Street. (Photo by Lindsey Stroud)

However, city staff recently determined it would be “more efficient and economical” to clean the sidewalks periodically rather than stain them.

Staff also noted that future sidewalk repairs could “disrupt the consistency of stain appearance and detract from the aesthetics of the district, rather than enhancing them.”

Crestview City Manager Jessica Leavins said that “due to the lifespan of the staining and sealing, and the increased events we are having downtown, (the stained sidewalks) would actually have a shorter lifespan.”

Leavins encouraged members to redirect funding toward the multi-use path, stating the city “could either stain the existing sidewalks or build a new multi-use path.”

The multi-use path is being funded in part through federal dollars from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development and will run adjacent to Industrial Drive and the railroad tracks.

Main Street opening of multi-use path. (Photo by Lindsey Stroud)
Twin Hill Parks opening of multi-use path. (Photo by Lindsey Stroud)

City officials expressed support for the project.

“I’m just excited about this multi-use path,” said Councilwoman Dusty Allison.

Councilman Sylvester Echols added that he believed it “was the best use of the funds.”

Leavins reaffirmed that the city will continue to maintain the downtown area, stating that staff will keep “Main Street sidewalks clean and updated” and work to “protect and preserve” existing infrastructure.

Okaloosa County bans red-light cameras from county roads

The resolution, sponsored by Commissioner Trey Goodwin, passed in a 4-1 vote, with Commissioner Paul Mixon dissenting, after commissioners rejected a proposed amendment that would have narrowed the ban’s application outside municipal boundaries.

The resolution targets two categories of devices: traffic infraction detectors, commonly known as red-light cameras, and speed detection systems deployed in school zones. According to county officials, the county does not currently have either type of camera on county rights of way, but staff have received requests from cities to install them there.

Goodwin said the issue was prompted in part by a ruling from Broward County Judge Steven DeLuca, who found the statutory framework governing traffic camera citations violates constitutional due process. DeLuca ruled in a case involving the city of Sunrise that the camera enforcement system improperly shifts the burden of proof onto the accused.

“The cameras don’t identify a person, they identify a vehicle,” Goodwin said. “Instead of the government bearing the burden to prove the driver, it puts the onus on the accused to prove their innocence, and that violates all fundamental principles of procedural due process.”

He said the ruling does not directly bind the county but called it a likely preview of more legal challenges to come. The resolution applies only to county rights of way and does not affect camera programs operated by municipalities on their own roads or rights of way.

The board also said the resolution is unrelated to license plate reader systems, commonly known as Flock cameras, used by the Okaloosa County Sheriff’s Office.

During public comment, speakers offered differing views.

Okaloosa resident Tim Bryant told the board he supported the ban, arguing camera-based enforcement bypasses Florida’s driver’s license point system, meaning dangerous drivers are not identified or removed from the road.

“The cameras don’t make us safer, they just collect money,” Bryant said.

Crestview Mayor JB Whitten, who voted against red-light cameras in the past, said he supports speed zone cameras in school zones despite his general opposition to traffic cameras. Whitten said he approved the speed cameras after data showed persistent speeding near schools.

Whitten said a 30-day test phase at a middle school on Old Bethel Road recorded 847 violations, including one driver clocked at 56 mph in a 20-mph zone. He also said 89.1% of drivers issued tickets last year received only one, suggesting the cameras were changing driving behavior.

“The intent is not to make money, the intent is to change driver’s patterns,” Whitten said. He urged the board to vote against the resolution or, at minimum, to table it until the state determines whether to appeal DeLuca’s ruling.

During deliberations, Mixon proposed a “friendly amendment” that would have restricted the ban to county roads outside municipal boundaries, arguing the county should respect the home rule authority of its nine municipalities. Goodwin rejected the amendment, saying the existing resolution already preserved city and state authority over their own roads.

“I will live and die on due process,” Goodwin said. “It is dangerous to use safety as an excuse to override our Constitution.”

The board also noted past incidents in which private vendors working for municipalities placed cameras on county rights of way without board approval, requiring Public Works staff to remove and store the equipment after vendors did not respond to removal requests.

error: Content is protected !!