Gaetz outlines DCF overhaul as Zuraff case nears conclusion
Gaetz, R-Crestview, said he is drafting one or more bills with Sens. Jason Pizzo, NPA-Hollywood; Jennifer Bradley, R-Fleming Island; and Erin Grall, R-Fort Pierce; and that many of 34 recommendations issued by the Fifth Judicial Circuit grand jury will be incorporated into them.
The grand jury, which released a report on the case Aug. 27, described “heartbreaking systemic patterns of neglect and abuse, abrogation of statutory responsibilities, as well as operational failures” within the department, Gaetz said, referring to the report.

He said the panel found children were being exploited, abused and neglected, and that some children died.
“When the department was confronted with its failures, the department delayed, denied, lied and then did nothing,” Gaetz said.
The news conference occurred at the same time as a dependency hearing for Joy Zuraff, whose daughter was removed from their Navarre home in March 2024, when the child was 5, and placed with a foster caregiver in Jacksonville. The girl returned home June 10.
A final hearing is set for Dec. 10, marking the six months of post-reunification work required by state law.
Zuraff is under a gag order and did not speak at the news conference. Pizzo, an independent representing parts of Broward and Miami-Dade counties, has represented her since February and said he has spent more than 2,000 hours on the case.
Gaetz said the legislation would reform Chapter 39 of state statutes, starting with the premise that DCF may contract out services but not accountability, and the contracts should be performance-based and should have oversight from the department, the Legislature and the governor’s office, with family rights not varying from county to county.
Other provisions would create legal consequences for agency staff and contractors who falsify documents or testimony and would allow parents or guardians to present evidence and challenge department actions without that being used against them in proceedings.
The proposed legislation would restrict placing children great distances from their families when DCF cannot find closer alternatives and would require contractors to employ credentialed clinicians, with fines and contract cancellations if those needs are not met.
Gaetz said a decision to seek termination of parental rights should be approved by a DCF secretary instead of a lower-tiered employee, noting that the justice system treats parental termination as heavily as the death penalty. Gaetz noted that judges should have a stronger role as a “check” on the department.
The final provision would repeal sovereign immunity for DCF contractors. Gaetz said the change affects only civil liability and said contractors would not be immune from criminal charges if the legislation is passed.
Gaetz noted that he does not want investigators discouraged from removing children in actual danger and said hundreds of DCF employees are qualified and committed.
“If DCF and some of its contractors have failed, so has the Florida Legislature, and so have I,” he said. “I wish I could have, and I wish I would have known more and done more then, but now I will.”
Pizzo noted that Zuraff was a single mom and was expected to drive 13 hours round trip to see her child.
“She was set up to fail,” he said. “Every obstacle was inserted.”
A former assistant state attorney, Pizzo said the testimony he reviewed was largely hearsay. He defended Chapter 39’s confidentiality provision in principle, saying it has eroded accountability.























